Tools

UPDATE: The day the newsroom went quiet and Milwaukee coppers complained..

By John Jagler

Something was different Monday morning as my workday started at 3:00.  It took a few minutes to figure out what it was.  Then it hit me... the scanners were quiet.  That happens sometimes on Mondays.  The weekend sports guys from time to time have turned down the scanners.  The police radio calls can be annoying, but having been in this biz for nearly 20 years, you learn to drown it out and listen for key phrases... none bigger than "officer down".  This time, I couldn't blame the weekend crews.  The scanners were up and scanning.. but there is nothing coming through.  Turns out, there won't be anything for reporters and scanner enthusiasts to listen to.  The Milwaukee Police Department has officially switched over to its new digital system.  It's called Open Sky radio.  The system was purchased years ago and MPD has been working to get the bugs out. 

It's the bugs that has some officers worried.   I talked to a few cops who say there are "dead spots" in the system where no signal comes through.  They admitted that the old analog system wasn't perfect.  Sometimes you couldn't understand what an officer said over the radio, but one thing often did cut through the static.... a sense of urgency.  A tone of the call, not necessarily the words could often cut through any static issues in communicating when an officer was in trouble.

A quick check of the Googles shows other Milwaukee cops are talking too.  Badger Blogger is taking their responses.   If you have a comment, especially if you are man or woman in blue, please comment below...

UPDATE

We did a story about this Thursday on Wisconsin's Morning News...

 

 

 

 

Milwaukee Police Chief Edward Flynn has sent a memo to his officers (read it here) concerning their new police radios. After nearly a decade of trying to get the bugs out, this week the department made the switch from the analog radios to the digital OpenSky system. Trial runs of the system showed numerous problems including "dead spots" where the radios don't work.  Police officers have been complaining loudly about the system on internet message boards. The chief's memo says he's committed to the officers safety and they've worked with the company to fix many of the problems. He also urges the officers to report any problems they have.

Chief Flynn says they can't discard the system, which has cost 17-million dollars in taxpayer money. From the memo: " as frustrating as the change process has been, I am simply not in a position to discard Open Sky. This has been a seven-year project that has cost over $17 million in taxpayer money. It is a sunk cost. lowe you, as police officers and taxpayers, my best efforts to get a value return on that investment, one that simply cannot be remade, in the current economic environment, with new money."

Other communities, however, have ashcanned the system though. After many of the same problems, the city of New York ditched OpenSky, canceling a 2-billion dollar contract.

I spoke with the new President of the Milwaukee Police Association, Mike Crivello, about this.  Crivello says he's aware of the officer's concerns, but says he trusts that their safety and the safety of the public is the top priority of Chief Flynn and that decisions concerning the radio and anything else will be made in that regard. 

 We talked about this on WMN with MPD communications head Captain Andra Williams... take a listen..

Monday, Mar 8 at 9:59 PM EcurbZneder wrote ...

http://badgerblogger.com/?p=15822&cpage=1#comment-226714

38900143 Flag for moderation

Wednesday, Feb 17 at 11:11 AM RW wrote ...

It took Oakland County, MI EIGHT-YEARS to get the Open Sky radio system working. And still today, only a small fraction of the county has switched to it. One police officer told me that Open Sky is going to get someone hurt or worse. He says their complaints about Open Sky problems fall on deaf ears. The FD refuses to use it because on the first working house fire using Open Sky radios the background noise garbled the signal to the point communications couldn't be understood.

37748499 Flag for moderation

Monday, Feb 15 at 8:55 PM nbr wrote ...

For accurate facts and information regarding the FCC's 2013 Narrowbanding Mandate, visit http://wirelessradio.net

37655761 Flag for moderation

Saturday, Feb 13 at 3:33 PM Greg Matzek wrote ...

Listen here newsboy - there's a newsperson in the newsroom constantly. Might they have a volume hand? I dont go near that thing.

37559098 Flag for moderation

Friday, Feb 12 at 12:13 PM RF Engineer wrote ...

The OS MPD system is fundamentally flawed. It will never meet the officer's expectations until the number of tower sites is expanded to include at least as many system entry points as the old UHF system had. Remember when they said the County system only needed $8 million and one antenna on the US Bank building? Add $30M to that and count the sites. You cannot ignore the physics of radio signal propagation. Currently there is very little or no site coverage overlap either. Good Luck.

37497962 Flag for moderation

Friday, Feb 12 at 11:03 AM Good $ After Bad wrote ...

It's sad that MPD continues to poor in good money after bad! Why don't they use the OpenSky system for mobile data (which it was designed for) and work with Milwaukee Co? Assuming the OpenSky radios are P25, MPD should work with the county on a digital build out of the Milw Co system and use the OpenSky radios on the county system. That way they are not throwing away millions of dollars they have spent on radios.

37492498 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 6:30 PM CitizenListener wrote ...

To phase in the migration deadline of January 1, 2013, the FCC has established interim deadlines. The first important deadline is January 1, 2011, after which: The FCC will not grant applications for new voice operations or applications to expand the authorized contour of existing stations that use 25 kHz channels. Only narrowband authorizations will be granted. The FCC will prohibit manufacture or importation of new equipment that operates on 25 kHz channels. This will reduce the availabili

37458398 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 6:07 PM Trooper wrote ...

There is no fed mandate to police to go to digital. The jan 2013 addresses the mandate to narrowband VHF radios. Or move to another system. Do some more research! They are blowing smoke. Do they still have VHF radios in cars as backup radio?? That's what Pa is doing!

37457129 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 3:44 PM MWeiher wrote ...

A Federal Mandate to go digital? Was Capt Williams referring to the mandate to narrowband their UHF frequencies? That's hardly a mandate to buy a $17m system. As Milw County's Radio System Administrator, I'll be happy to tell you what happened there.

37447956 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 3:30 PM Petro Mendos wrote ...

The state of Pennslyvania has a statewide OPEN-SKY system for sereval years with 15,000 radios in service and claims a coverage rate of over 95% of most counties ,Which is the industry standard In OAKLAND COUNTY MICHIGAN there are serveral cities including yhe city of PONTIAC, that are using OPEN-SKY with not many problems being reported. So not all is negative about OPEN-SKY technolgy.

37446928 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 2:13 PM Correction wrote ...

This is not correct: "Other communities, however, have ashcanned the system though. After many of the same problems, the city of New York ditched OpenSky, despite spending 2-billion dollars." It was decided to not go with the system during early testing long before anywhere near than amount of money was spent.

37441496 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 2:11 PM Really? wrote ...

Guess what? There is no such thing as a radio system without dead spots...analog or digital, low band or high band.

37441369 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 12:52 PM Scan Geek wrote ...

WRONG! There is NO federal mandate to go digital Jan 2013! No other agencies in Milw Co will be digital by then.

37436093 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 10:08 AM Calvin wrote ...

And WHERE is Tom Barrett on this issue??? He just gets a completely free pass from the Media. If this were a Milwaukee County radio system, it would all be Walker's fault.

37424303 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Feb 11 at 8:16 AM gymdawg wrote ...

But digital HAS to be better!

37418056 Flag for moderation

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

620WTMJ and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.