Tools

FLASHBACK: THE SHAME OF REMBERT WEAKLAND

By Charlie Sykes

Dramatic admission from the former archbishop.....

Retired Archbishop Rembert Weakland admitted in a video deposition released Wednesday that he transferred priests with a history of sexual misconduct back into churches without alerting parishioners.

The former archbishop acknowledged that he did so because "no parish would have accepted a priest unless you could say that he has gone through the kind of psychological examination and that he's not a risk to the parish."

**

I'm reposting a column I wrote in 2002:

The shame of Rembert Weakland
Milwaukee
archbishop tolerated and protected priestly sexual abuse
By Charles J. Sykes


Even years later, he's haunted by the casual greeting: "Hi, Greg."

He was lying in bed, the bed of a Catholic priest. The priest, Father Dennis Pecore, had gotten up and answered the knock at his door. He stood in the doorway in his bathrobe, talking with another priest, who had come to his room. The visitor could see the boy lying in the bed. "Hi, Greg," he said to the boy.

"Nothing else was said or asked of me," recalls Greg. He was 14 years old.

Greg is just one of hundreds of young men who were sexually abused by priests they trusted. But his case casts a shadow over the Milwaukee archdiocese and the legacy of Archbishop Rembert Weakland.

It should. Because Weakland's handling of this case stands as his most shameful moment.

By the mid-1980s, it was an open secret that Pecore was using Greg, a student at the Mother of Good Counsel School, as a sex toy. Greg says that other priests knew, as well as teachers and school officials. "My mother used to call up at the rectory and they would say that I was not there, and she would ride by and see my bike out front and know I was at the rectory."

In July 1984, one of the school's teachers had become so alarmed that he wrote a letter informing Archbishop Weakland that a priest at the school was taking young boys to his private bedroom, one at a time, suggesting that he was abusing the youngsters. He urged Weakland to do something "before it goes public."

Weakland's response: a threat. He wrote that "any libelous material found in your letter will be scrutinized carefully by our lawyers."

Frustrated, the teacher and two others continued to warn about Pecore's behavior. All three teachers were fired. In a lawsuit filed several years later, the three teachers say they were fired because they had tried to warn Weakland about what was happening at their school.

There is no evidence that Weakland took any other action in response to the warnings. Instead, the teachers later said, the church "conspired to silence this situation and to terminate" the whistleblowers.

In early 1987, Father Pecore was charged with sexual assault. He was later sentenced to a year in jail. (Several years later, after he was charged with molesting another boy, he was given a 12-year prison sentence.) The archdiocese also agreed to pay Greg and his family $595,000 in an out-of-court settlement.

Weakland insisted that the agreement be kept secret. "It was the archdiocese's idea to seal it," Greg later wrote a Milwaukee judge, "and when our family saw the clause in the agreement that it was to be sealed, we strongly objected."

Greg rejects the idea that the secrecy was designed to protect him: "If the archdiocese wanted to protect me, they would have not put me through all the hassles they did."

Weakland, however, wanted the last word. In a column published in the archdiocese's newspaper, the archbishop suggested that the adolescent victims were not so "innocent" after all. "Some of them," Weakland wrote at the time, "can be sexually very active and aggressive and often quite streetwise."

Even back in 1988, prosecutors were stunned by Weakland's victim-must-share-the-blame attitude. The head of Milwaukee's sensitive crimes unit said he was "disappointed and saddened" by Weakland's comments, noting that Milwaukee 's archbishop was either "failing or choosing to ignore the obvious power differential that exists between a priest and child."

Then-assistant district attorney (and now judge) John DiMotto said that he had never known a case where a child had enticed a priest.

To this day, Weakland's actions and words still carry the power to wound.

"To me, looking back on it now," says Greg, "how could he even suggest that? I was so young at the time. I couldn't make a decision like that."

He's still disgusted by the secrecy. "I wanted to tell my story to everyone," says Greg. "I wanted to get this out. I wasn't afraid to tell what happened to me. And I felt bad for the teachers who lost their job, the principal at the school, who had to leave because of this. I wanted this out in the open."

Greg believes the teachers fired by the archdiocese "were trying to protect me, trying to help me. The teachers who lost their jobs were 100% behind my family through this whole thing."

Milwaukee 's archbishop, however, has been a different story. Rembert Weakland has nothing to say about Greg or his case. The church's secrecy, tolerance and denial of sexual abuse has become a cancer on the church.

In Milwaukee , the archbishop carries into retirement the burden of his silence.

 

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 8:16 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Seeking justice for those abused is the goal of SNAP. Concentrate on that not revenge on Rembert Weakland. He is here facing the music when he could have escaped to another place to retire. Let's work with him,notuse him for our anger. Lee Held

35374852 Flag for moderation

Monday, Jan 11 at 9:38 PM Jeanne Thom wrote ...

May God strike the whole cathedral and level it to the ground if the bronze of Weakland is not removed! He left office in disgrace and did a great disservice to many people whom he was entrusted to care for. St. John of the Cross said, "the floor in hell is paved with the skulls of bishops." May God have mercy on his soul. I pray for all the innocent victims that were harmed by his appointments and decisions. May they be given the grace to forgive their oppressors.

35353487 Flag for moderation

Friday, Jan 8 at 9:48 AM mickster wrote ...

Throughout it's history the Catholic Church has been nothing other than a corrupt self serving organization. Why expect anything different today.

35135189 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 7:39 PM Kenneth M. Fisher, Founder & Chrmn, Concerned Roman Catholics of America, Inc. wrote ...

Weakland was a 'Key Note Speaker" at one of Cdl. Mahony's dissent fest, the Archdiocese of Lost Angels Religious Education Congress. Catholic parents, beware! \

35101462 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 1:30 PM Debra Josiger-Holzem wrote ...

These articles make me so sad. Almost every day I see things in the institutional church that make me know how very little learning has taken place from the mistakes of the past.

35076807 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 1:21 PM THOMAS JOSHUA wrote ...

THE GOVERNMENT IS AT FAULT. IF THE FIRST PRIEST TO GET CAUGHT HAD BEEN GIVEN THE DEATH PENALTY AS HE DESERVED, OTHER PRIESTS WOULD HAVE THOUGHT TWICE BEFORE COMMITTING SUCH ABOMINATIONS.

35075942 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 12:35 PM emma wrote ...

Rembert Weakland is an evil man. Those who support him are evil, also. A statue to a Judas Priest??? It should be melted down and destroyed.

35071382 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 11:56 AM Helen Erskine wrote ...

As a surviver of pedeophilia, I know forgiveness is a basic stone in the foundation of healing. Having the Catholic Church celebrate Archbishop Weakland, by having his image as a "Modern Christ" protecting Children today, is wrong. Forgiveness does not mean blindness. A culture displays itself through art. Does the Official Catholic Church really consider Archbishop Weakland a protector of children? There are many good things that Archbishop Weakland did. Protection of Children is not one.

35067952 Flag for moderation

Thursday, Jan 7 at 8:26 AM Lorrie Greco wrote ...

What is the path to the most constructive resolution to all this! We have dilly dallied long enough. It is in the best interest of our diocese to get to it and get past it. Dear God, will there ever a time when we can say that all this is behind us to the extent that we can appreciate both the good accomplishments of these bishops as well as the bad? Bronze can be melted and reformed. Could we cast a brand new piece to depict a new and better reality?

35050719 Flag for moderation

Wednesday, Jan 6 at 11:52 PM Stan Powers wrote ...

This IS very creepy of Weakland "protecting" those children in a bronze art piece. He could NOT do so in real life as Archbishop shredding child abuse reports by priests in his office, shuffling around priests who abuse kids, but, wishes to be immortalized in bronze doing so? One can only wonder why? Perhaps a conscious guilt of what he is not? And, $100K for that? It should be removed, SNAP is correct! Art is not imitating life in this bronze! Stan Powers, Milwaukee

35035982 Flag for moderation

Wednesday, Jan 6 at 6:21 PM Ken Fauster wrote ...

Weakland, serves himself, not God! Perhaps he should have made the bronze of a penis with a Bishops miter on it it would be in keeping with his sinning such a jerk

35020094 Flag for moderation

Wednesday, Jan 6 at 4:54 PM christoffelcarol@yahoo.com wrote ...

This is disgusting.When Christ said "Suffer little children to come unto me."it was in the context of a SAFE person. The Church perverts and cover-ups have made a mockery of it, reducing it to "Suffer little Children".

35014702 Flag for moderation

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

620WTMJ and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Summerfest