Story Created:
May 15, 2008
Story Updated:
May 16, 2008
Here is the email I read yesterday:
Don't usually read the MJS Food section, but today I scsanned its "10 Nifty Tips for Being Thrifty: Shop smart, cut waste to stretch your food dollar"
They could have saved a lot of ink by simply writing "One Big Tip for stretching your food dollar" - Shop at Woodmans!! If you look at the comparison price chart they run it is striking how Woodmans is consistently and dramatically cheaper. That was no surprise to me. Our family has loved Woodmans ever since living in Madison. They have everything, they don't play the constantly rotating loss leader game like Pick and Save, their prices are what you see is what you get. They don't make you apply for a special customer card that captures your personal information and ledts demographers track your shopping. They are the Wal Mart of grocery stores. IN fact, the prices are so dramatically different that for our family of 5, we time our major grocery shopping to coincide with either my trips to Madison or our regulare trips to Racine (past the new Oak Creek Woodmans) to visit my folks.
Ironically, leftists hate Woodmans almost as much as Wal Mart. Woodmans are non-union and employee owned. Just last week there were major union protests in Janesville targeting Woodmans because their employees refuse to organize. Like Wal Mart, Woodmas' are often opposed by the anti "big box" crowd because their stores are massive. But as you can see in black and white in today's paper, like Wal Mart, Woodmans is a major inflation buster for familes struggling to make ends meet today. (and the dirty little secret is that lefties in Madison shop there to get the low prices, even as they complain about non-union big boxes)
Woodmans doesn't advertise - another way they keep costs down - so I'm not surprised that the MJS wouldn't explicitly shill for them over massive MJS advertisers like Pick and Save and Sendiks and Sentry, but I am not similarly constrained and I will shill shamelessly. Want to make your food dollars go further? Shop at Woodmans!!!
p.s. I also find it interesting that the opening of a high cost, high end food store - Whole Foods - in Milwaukee got about a week solid of hype in the MJS but when the new Oak Creek Woodmans opened it I think it got about 2 paragraphs in the Business Section.
**
And here is the story about the liberal assault on Woodman's.
A move is under way to get rid of the long-established unions at area Woodman's grocery stores and union leaders are pointing the finger at owner Phil Woodman.
"The question everyone is asking is why is Phil Woodman taking such an aggressive stance against his hard-working employees,'' said John Eiden, president of United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1473, which represents Woodman's grocery workers and meat cutters.
A spokesman for Woodman says it's the workers themselves who are questioning the value of being in the union.
**
Email from JS reporter:
Mr. Sykes,
Your listener who emailed you about Woodman’s incorrectly implied that the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel has deliberately down played coverage of its new Oak Creek store. In fact, the Journal Sentinel has written about the Oak Creek store on multiple occasions. I personally broke the story (on Nov. 4, 2005) in reporting Woodman’s plans for Oak Creek. We’re referred to the store on several occasions since then. More recently, my colleague, Doris Hajewski, wrote a lengthy article about Woodman’s when it opened the Oak Creek store in March. A link to the story is attached.
I would appreciate it if could add this item to your blog to set the record straight.
Thanks
Tom Daykin
Business reporter
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
http://www.jsonline.com/story/index.aspx?id=733343
Monday, May 26 at 10:19 AM gfk wrote ...
I'm now confused! Is Phil Woodman treating his employees badly with threats and intimidation or is this just a scheme cooked up by the union? I am a union member(not this union), and I can't say that I'm all that impressed with them. They are good for some things. I'd like the straight scoop on this please. I shop Woodmans regularly because they are the least expensive and have a good selection.
Saturday, May 24 at 4:26 PM woodman's employee wrote ...
actually, 6 of our 12 stores maybe union affiliated but we are no longer recognizing the union at those stores because the vast majority of the employees signed a petition to get rid of those money hungry good for nothing leeches on society. 200 of 280 employees at the woodman's east store signed. the truth is there are few of us who want the union and shouldn't it be our choice? afterall we are EMPLOYEE OWNED, phil is only respecting the wishes of his fellow owners/ employees of the store!
Friday, May 23 at 3:25 PM woodman worker wrote ...
Woodmans does not need the union. It does nothing for the workers.NO pension, Woodmans pulled out of that dead horse. NO insurance Woodmans offers better and CHEAPER than the union. Union dues are only for the union to spend on bashing Phil Woodman and keeping the jobs of people that were rightly fired. Keep shopping Employee Owned WOODMANs thank-you
Sunday, May 18 at 2:00 PM Gregg wrote ...
union or non-union, I prefer to do business with a company that treats it's costomers, and employees, like human beings. I'll shop empoyee owned.
Friday, May 16 at 11:01 AM bigcat wrote ...
Mary, Now that you know that 6 of the 12 Woodman's stores are union affiliated, will you stop shopping there? IS your hatred of unions that pure, or will you continue to patronize the food chain?
Friday, May 16 at 10:05 AM You Know Who wrote ...
Woodmans is the Eighth Wonder of the World. If you don't save at Woodmans you are a lost cause. Cheaper than Wal-Mart and their perishibles are light years ahead of Wal Mart.....And when did union employees become hard workers? Saying and doing are two different things and they only seem to have only one right, the saying part.
Friday, May 16 at 7:35 AM Mary wrote ...
Actually, Woodman's is doing a little advertising in this market to call attention to their store. The ads really ARE awful. Note to Phil Woodman: Stop the paid advertising, it's bad and you don't need it.
Friday, May 16 at 7:33 AM Mary wrote ...
Bigcat- "Please shop at Woodman's...6 OF ITS 12 stores are UNION AFFILIATED!" Not for long!
Thursday, May 15 at 11:29 PM Crazy Politico wrote ...
I do shop Woodman's occasionally, since the Kenosha store is only 15 minutes away, they are great for some specialty stuff and beers I can't get elsewhere. The prices are definitely lower than the Jewel in my town (In Illinois). However, for every day shopping Super Wal-Mart is cheaper yet, and I shop to save my pocketbook, not to make sure someone else get's taken care of.
Thursday, May 15 at 11:10 PM Dan wrote ...
bigcat, just think how much lower the prices would be without the union.
Thursday, May 15 at 8:44 PM g wrote ...
To Whitefish Bay Mike: WHAT??? Are you being ironic??? I'm not a Union man, but...WHAT???
Thursday, May 15 at 3:06 PM BigT wrote ...
Thanks for the article Charlie. I'm going to go out of my way to shop at Woodman's.
Thursday, May 15 at 2:20 PM Whitefish Bay Mike wrote ...
I don't want to get to deep here, but many Bible verses indicate that people may be eternally separated from God if they are members of evil organizations like the United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1473. "Food" for thought.
Thursday, May 15 at 1:00 PM Your Mom wrote ...
That email says that Woodman's doesn't advertise, but they do. They have hilariously awful television ads. "Wow, our prices are low! Wow!"
Thursday, May 15 at 12:28 PM bigcat wrote ...
Mary, Please shop at Woodman's...6 OF ITS 12 stores are UNION AFFILIATED! They have always kept prices low at all their stores and are a shining example of the power of unions to provide decent wages for all employees(the non-union employees benefit from the wage and benefit packages negotiated by their union peers at the Woodman chain).
Thursday, May 15 at 10:18 AM Amy P wrote ...
Apparently, liberals are against anything that saves people money unless it's a government, nanny-state subsidy. My grocery bill dropped by 50% when I started shopping at Woodmans. The formula I used to buy for my son is $6.00 LESS at Woodmans. The free market is a wonderful thing and I cannot afford to shop at Sendiks, Whole Foods, or Pick N Save (when it's the only option in the market). Leave Woodmans - MY grocery store - alone!
Thursday, May 15 at 9:49 AM Jugdish wrote ...
Union, Shmunion.......I don't care, the fact is Woodmans is cheaper by a longshot. Unions are ruining this coutry's ability to compete; don't believe me......look at the US automakers.
Thursday, May 15 at 9:10 AM Mary wrote ...
bigcat, We KNOW the WHOLE story. It's posted right here. You must be the product of MPS. Furthermore, we don't CARE what the union flack thinks; he's a union flack. We LOVE Woodman's!! Go ahead and shop at the union food stores if you don't mind paying 25% more for your food than you need to.
Thursday, May 15 at 8:36 AM aldi shopper wrote ...
Woodmans is great, but takes 1 1/2 hours to shop. I can do a weeks worth of grocery shopping at ALdi's and get out in about 25 minutes. Sweet! I welcome Woodmans, though, having several low cost options is a great thing.
Thursday, May 15 at 8:24 AM bigcat wrote ...
Before posting e-mails, you may want to fact check them. 6 of the 12 Woodman's stores are union stores. FROM JANESVILLE GAZETTE "Woodman’s stories on The Janesville Gazette Web site have said the movement to decertify Local 1473 is management-driven. John Eiden, president of Local 1473, said he’s certain chain president Phil Woodman and Grubb’s firm instigated the effort. He said the Vermont-based Grubb appeared on the scene shortly after Phil came back from a union-avoidance seminar"
Add a comment
Most Popular