620 WTMJ
  • Radar
  • Forecast
  • Live Cams

Milwaukee Weather

Radar
Sunday, November 8
More Weather
  • News
  • Weather
  • Traffic
  • Sports
  • Shows
  • Loyal Listener Club
  • Contest
  • Events
  • Closings
  • About Us
  • Listen Live
  • Jobs
  • CarSoup
  • Local Headlines
  • National Headlines
  • World Headlines
  • AP Pictures
  • Businesses Go Green
Green Bay Removes Nativity Scene, But Not Lawsuit

The nativity scene the City of Green Bay established. | Photo: NBC26

Tools

  • Email this article
  • Print this article
  • Digg this!
  • Save to Delicious
  • Post to Facebook
Close

Green Bay Removes Nativity Scene, But Not Lawsuit

Story Created: May 15, 2009

Story Updated: May 15, 2009

Click here to listen to Newsradio 620 WTMJ's Vicky Hollowell report on the impending lawsuit the city of Green Bay faces from the Freedom From Religion Foundation about the city's Nativity scene.

GREEN BAY, Wis. (AP) -- An organization of atheists and agnostics won't drop its federal lawsuit against the city of Green Bay even though the nativity scene that sparked the suit was taken down from City Hall Wednesday morning.

The Madison-based Freedom From Religion Foundation will continue with its suit, which co-president Annie Laurie Gaylor expected would be officially filed Wednesday or Thursday.

Even if the city argues that the issue is moot since the display is gone, "we want a court ruling that they can't do it again," Gaylor said.

Their lawsuit claims the display depicting the birth of Jesus is an unconstitutional governmental endorsement of religion. Among other things, it asks a federal judge to declare the city's actions a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.

Workers removed the nativity scene and a Santa Claus display from the overhangs to the two main entrances of City Hall.

The lawsuit, dated Dec. 24, claims City Council President Chad Fradette and Mayor Jim Schmitt allowed the display to provoke and marginalize those who would object.

After the city allowed Fradette to install the scene, Schmitt said he had to grant requests for other religious displays. Among those installed was a wreath containing a pentacle, a five-pointed star that is an important symbol for the Wicca religion. The wreath was later removed by vandals.

A suburban resident sarcastically asked the city to install a pole symbolizing Festivus, a holiday popularized in an episode of TV's "Seinfeld." Another resident asked for a symbol honoring the "Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster."

Schmitt imposed a moratorium on religious symbols. Following a divisive debate over whether the city should sponsor the nativity scene, the city council voted 4-1 to keep the display but put all other requests on hold until it could draw up guidelines.

Twelve local residents opposed to the display are joining the suit. They include a Unitarian Universalist, an agnostic and a devout Buddhist who wants permission to put up his own religious symbol in May.

(Copyright 2007 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

Most Popular

  • Deputy Shoots Inmate at Waukesha Hospital
  • Missing Child Found
  • Palin Visits West Allis
  • Young Woman Shot in Milwaukee
  • Face to Face with Ft. Hood Gunman
Advanced Search
Legal Line
MyHomeImprovment

Cabinet Refinishing
Carpet
Foundation or Basements Repair / Waterproofing
Garage Doors & Openers
Gutters
Heating & Cooling
Painting Contractor
Roofing
Sewer & Drain
Siding
Window Treatment
Windows

VIEW ALL PROS!

Milwaukee Marketplace

  • Tickets
  • Promo Codes
  • Coupons
  • Gift Certificates
Go Green


Check This Out

On Demand

  • Follow us on Twitter! Follow us on Twitter!
  • Facebook Facebook
  • Podcasts Podcasts

    Podcasts Read more »

  • Listen Live Listen Live

    Listen to Newsradio 620 WTMJ over the Internet Read more »

  • Text Alerts Text Alerts

    620WTMJ Text Alerts Read more »

  • Mobile Mobile

    620WTMJ Mobile Read more »

  • eNews & eNews Alerts eNews & eNews Alerts
  • Your Story Your Story
  • RSS Feeds RSS Feeds

    RSS Feeds Read more »

  • Contact Us Contact Us

    Contact 620WTMJ Read more »

More On Demand

Shows

  • Wisconsin's Morning News Wisconsin's Morning News

    Wake up smarter! It’s all you need to know! Read more »

  • Charlie Sykes Charlie Sykes

    Compelling and entertaining local talk radio – Milwaukee’s #1 Read more »

  • Jeff Wagner Jeff Wagner

    The Department of Justice - he’s got issues! Read more »

  • Clark Howard Clark Howard

    Saves you money and keeps you from getting ripped off! Read more »

  • The Green House The Green House

    Have fun with Jon and Bill while you get the news and sports of the day! Read more »

  • Sports Central Sports Central

    Sports Talk like only the Big Unit can deliver! Read more »

  • The Dennis Miller Show The Dennis Miller Show

    Comedian, conservative -- a must-listen! Read more »

  • James T. Harris James T. Harris

    Newest TMJ talker – don’t miss
    The National Conversation!

    Read more »

More Shows
Copyright © 2009
Journal Broadcast Group, a Journal Communications Inc. company
EEO
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Powered by Broadcast Interactive Media.