Swing...and a miss. Phantom Yankee catch needs to be seen to be believed
Think we need replay in baseball?
Watch this, and then let's talk.
No, I don't think we need more replays, at least not in cases like this. What we need are umpires who do their jobs. Sure, the men in blue might've missed what happened once the outfielder went into the seats, but don't you ask to see the ball to make sure it was in his glove? If the fielder had made the play, no doubt he would've been raising it and waving it for all to see. He didn't, though, so he couldn't.
Yes, there are occasions where the camera would settle close calls. This isn't one of them.